Italian Citizenship

Tribunale di Trieste: Recognition of Citizenship by Jus Sanguinis

Tribunal of Trieste (decision no. 2713/2026, published 11/18/2026) recognizes Italian citizenship by descent and orders civil registry actions through a judicial challenge to administrative omission.

Tribunale di Trieste: Recognition of Citizenship by Jus Sanguinis
Foto: Babak Habibi (Pexels)

Tribunale di Trieste: recognition of citizenship by jus sanguinis

The Tribunale di Trieste, in the sentence n. 2713/2026 published on 18/11/2026, recognized Italian citizenship by descent (ius sanguinis) to an applicant and ordered the Ministry and the ufficiale dello stato civile to proceed with the registrations, transcriptions and annotations required in the civil records, after a court action motivated by administrative omission. Below is a summary and essential observations, including warnings about recent legislative changes that affect administrative and consular avenues.

Summary of the decision — Tribunale di Trieste, judicial recognition of Italian citizenship

The Tribunal of Trieste (sentence n. 2713/2026, R.G. 714/25) granted the applicant's request and declared him a cittadino italiano per ius sanguinis, according to the text of the decision published by Diritto Pratico: https://apps.dirittopratico.it/sentenze.html?c=https://apps.dirittopratico.it/sentenza/tribunale/trieste/2026/2713.html#2fce0. The competent Ministry did not appear in the process and was declared in default; the judge ordered that the Ministry and the ufficiale dello stato civile proceed with the iscrizioni, trascrizioni e annotazioni by law. The documents presented by the claimant were apostilled and translated; there were no acts of renunciation by the applicant himself or by the ancestor whose nationality was invoked.

Main legal bases — jus sanguinis and documentary evidence

The Tribunal applied Law 5 February 1992, n. 91, which enshrines the principle of ius sanguinis: a person is Italian by birth if he has an Italian father or mother.

"È cittadino italiano per nascita chiunque ha padre o madre cittadini italiani." (L. 5 febb. 1992, n. 91)

The judge verified the descent line based on the attached certificates (doc. 1 and doc. 3-10) and found no atto di rinuncia (doc. 2). It was concluded that the citizenship status existed from the birth of the precursor and, therefore, must be recognized in favor of the applicant. The Tribunal also considered the paralysis and delay of consular authorities as a factor that justifies the judicial path, citing art. 2 of Law 7 August 1990, n. 241 (the administrative procedure rule) and the principle of ragionevole durata del processo. However, it should be noted that the configuration of implicit denial and the admissibility of the judicial action depend on the specific circumstances of the case.

ESSENTIAL WARNINGS about recent legislative changes (Tajani Decree / DL 36/2025 — L. 74/2025)

  • Since the Tajani Decree (DL 36/2025, converted into L. 74/2025), there have been significant changes that restrict administrative and consular avenues for recognition. In particular, the consular route is ordinarily limited to children and grandchildren; subsequent generations (for example, great-grandchildren) can no longer obtain recognition via the consulate under ordinary conditions. This restriction is substantive and affects access to recognition administratively.
  • The Tajani Decree has material retroactive effects on citizenship law: it states that certain people born abroad who are not children or grandchildren of Italians have “never been” Italians. This is not limited to ongoing processes, as it affects substantive rights at birth. The question of compatibility of this retroactivity with constitutional principles has been the subject of judicial challenges, but the existence and wording of the rule are legally relevant for applicants.
  • Consequently, readers (especially great-grandchildren and later generations) should not assume that consular routes or administrative recognition by comune remain applicable as they did before 2025. Procedures and strategies should be evaluated case by case with a specialized attorney, considering the restrictions introduced by DL 36/2025 and any pending judicial challenges.
  • Proceedings filed BEFORE the Tajani Decree came into force may have specific protections provided in the decree text itself; this procedural protection differs from the question of the material retroactivity of the law.

What this means in practice for Brazilian families — via judicial action against administrative omission

  • The decision confirms that, in concrete cases, delays or omissions by the consulate or the Ministry can justify an azione giudiziale to obtain citizenship recognition by blood. However, note: since DL 36/2025 consular avenues are restricted to certain generations (see above).
  • When documentary evidence is in order — apostilled and translated certificates proving the line of descent — the judicial path can, in many cases, result in a judgment requiring the recognition to be registered in the registro civile italiano. Even so, the administrative execution of the judgment may face practical issues when the matter touches the application of DL 36/2025; thus, legal follow-up is essential.
  • The judgment not only recognizes the individual but also requires the trascrizione/iscrizione of acts in the Italian civil state registers and communication to the competent consular authorities, when applicable. Effective annotation and subsequent administrative effects depend on the applicable legal framework to the specific case.

Deadlines, proof and costs — practical guidance

  • Gather birth, marriage and death certificates of the direct line ancestors, all apostilled under the Hague Convention and translated by a certified translator. Documentation proving the line of descent is essential.
  • If the consulate delays or does not issue a decision, the judicial route may be legitimate, but the possibility of implicit denial and the viability of the action depend on the case, the competent authority, and the legal framework (including the restrictions of DL 36/2025).
  • Regarding procedural costs, the Tribunal, in this particular case, offset the expenses given the administrative nature of the request and the absence of a formal act of refusal by the administrative body. This decision does not guarantee that all similar cases will have costs reimbursed; the assessment is discretionary and depends on the case circumstances.

How to proceed after a favorable decision and source

After the ruling — and once it becomes final — the Ministry and the ufficiale dello stato civile must comply with the order of registration/transcription/annotation. It may be necessary to monitor the adempimento of the sentence and, if there is resistance, to pursue enforcement measures. In particular, when the matter conflicts with the restrictions of DL 36/2025, it is advisable to consult with a lawyer about enforcement strategies and procedural risks. The primary source of the decision is Diritto Pratico: https://apps.dirittopratico.it/sentenze.html?c=https://apps.dirittopratico.it/sentenza/tribunale/trieste/2026/2713.html#2fce0 (sentence no. 2713/2026, published 18/11/2026), on which the facts reported in this article are based. To assess the viability of a judicial action and prepare documentary evidence, it is advisable to consult a lawyer specialized in Cidadania Italiana.

Conclusion: the Tribunale di Trieste’s decision reinforces that the judicial path remains an alternative to obtain recognition of Italian citizenship when there is robust documentation and administrative omission. However, since the Tajani Decree (DL 36/2025 / L. 74/2025) there are relevant administrative and consular restrictions — particularly for great-grandchildren and later generations — and there are issues of material retroactivity that can affect the practical execution of recognitions. Seek up-to-date legal advice before making procedural decisions.

Read next