Cassation confirms Roggero's conviction for deliberate aggression
The Italian Supreme Court confirms Mario Roggero's 14 years 9 months sentence, ruling his 2021 actions were a 'deliberate aggression' and not legitimate self-defense.

The Supreme Court of Cassation confirmed the definitive sentence of 14 years and 9 months against jeweler Mario Roggero for causing the deaths of two men during a robbery that occurred on April 28, 2021 at his establishment in Grinzane Cavour (province of Cuneo), concluding that his action was a "deliberata aggressione" and not eligible for legitimate defense. According to ANSA, the decision of the 1st criminal section made the sentence definitive and removed coverage by legitimate defense.
Case Summary
- On April 28, 2021, inside his shop in Grinzane Cavour, Roggero fired at three men who, according to the prosecution, were committing a robbery: two died and one was injured.
- The final sentence, in last instance, is 14 years and 9 months in prison, now confirmed by the Court of Cassation.
- The definitive decision was communicated by the Supreme Court and detailed in its motivation, which Cassation released in a document dated July 15 (published and cited by the press, according to ANSA).
Motives of Cassation
Judges of the 1st criminal section of the Court of Cassation stated that Roggero's conduct cannot be classified as a mere miscalculation or act of imprudence. The Court qualified the conduct as "deliberata aggressione", understanding it as a voluntary and conscious choice to attack the robbers.
- Cassation held that the defense of legitimate self-defense cannot be applied, neither in its real nor putative form, in this case.
- In its motivation, the magistrates highlighted evidentiary elements that, in the Court's assessment, demonstrated the intention to act on his own, rather than merely taking necessary acts of immediate protection.
(In highlight of the motivation: > "deliberata aggressione", a term used by the Court to describe Roggero's action.)
Behavior of the Condemned and Cited Evidence
The magistrates recorded a set of behaviors and circumstances that, according to Cassation, indicate the intention to "farsi giustizia da sé" (do justice with one’s own hands). Among the points raised are:
- Testimonies and technical evidence about the dynamics of the shooting and the positions of those involved at the time of the events.
- Interviews and public statements by Roggero after the episode, in which he asserted that his initiative was the only way to stop the thieves and bring them to justice — a stance the Court interpreted as reinforcing the deliberate choice to act on his own.
ANSA reported that the Court's motivation, published on July 15, details these reasons and reaffirms the exclusion of legitimate defense as a ground for illegality.
Procedural and Incarceration Status
The final motivation of Cassation was prepared in a document dated July 15, making the sentence definitive. The matter also notes, in a caption accompanying press images, Roggero's arrival at Bollate prison, in Milan, on July 17, 2026. According to ANSA's coverage, this arrival occurred in fulfillment of the sentence execution order following the conviction confirmation.
The case progressed through the ordinary courts up to the Supreme Court, which, upon reviewing the grounds of the appeal, upheld the conviction and characterized it as noted above.
Relevance for Brazilians and Italian Descendants
The Cassation decision has practical implications for people living in or with family ties to Italy, including Brazilians and descendants of Italians, because it illustrates the Italian criminal justice system's narrow interpretation of legitimate defense and property protection.
- Cases involving violence on private property and self-protection acts can result in severe criminal liability when the conduct is deemed disproportionate or driven by punitive intent.
- For readers interested in Italy's life and legal issues, the decision underscores the importance of understanding the local legal framework and the differences between self-protection practices and actions that the Court may qualify as deliberate aggression.
See also: News from Italy, Life in Italy and information about Italian Citizenship for those considering relocation or processes based on family ties.
Source: ANSA.





